Thursday, November 19, 2026

Supply Commitments Aren’t What They Used To Be

Dear Editor,

The November 14 Globe and Mail had an article containing very bad news for residents of New England.

The article should serve as a very important warning to the people and Government of Ontario. And it is very relevant to every one of us here in Meaford.

I wrote to you in December 2025 about the supply problems Hydro-Quebec and Manitoba Hydro were having. At the time, I said, “Manitoba Hydro and Quebec both say they have firm commitments to sell their excess hydro already. They’re already struggling to provide enough for their own future growth. Currently Quebec is a net importer of hydro.”

I wrote that then because Save Georgian Bay and their supporters continued to spread their fantasy that Ontario wouldn’t need pumped storage electricity from Meaford if we would just purchase “excess electricity from Quebec”.

Well. It’s gotten even worse in Quebec – for their existing electricity customers.

From the Globe article:

Hydro-Quebec, “…Canada’s biggest producer of hydroelectricity, says it is dealing with its four driest consecutive years since hydrological data began to be compiled in the 1940s. Record-low runoff conditions that started in 2023 have not let up and reservoirs have not filled back up significantly.”

“Demand for Hydro-Québec’s power continues to increase, forcing the company to carefully manage its resources. The utility is limiting its power sales on spot markets outside Quebec…”

“Last winter, during two multiday cold snaps in January and February, Hydro-Québec halted energy deliveries to three electric utilities in Massachusetts to protect the safety and reliability of its grid. Deliveries stopped a little more than a week after they started under a new 20-year supply contract.”

I sure hope those New England residents (who may end up shivering in the dark this winter) were not told, “We don’t need our own energy storage capability. We’ll just purchase excess electricity from Quebec. It will be simple. And we’ll save tons of money.”

Just like we were told here. And are still being told here.

What did the opposition to Meaford Pumped Storage have to say on the subject of energy storage for Ontario?

The Georgian Bay Alliance and Save Georgian Bay believe:

“The Georgian Bay Association (GBA) and partner groups advocate for expanding east-west electricity transmission from Quebec as a cleaner, lower-cost alternative to building TC Energy’s proposed pumped storage facility at Meaford. Alongside grassroots ally Save Georgian Bay (SGB), the GBA argues that tapping into Hydro-Québec’s existing hydroelectric reservoirs meets Ontario’s energy storage needs without risking Georgian Bay’s ecosystem.”

Oops. That’s a swing and a miss. Did anyone else weigh in?

The Ontario Clean Air Alliance did:

“Use Quebec’s Hydro Reservoirs as Batteries: Quebec’s massive hydroelectric reservoir system can act as a giant storage battery. When Ontario has excess wind and solar power, it can send electricity to Quebec, and Quebec can hold back water. When Ontario needs power, Quebec can release water to generate and export power back.”

And in her submission to the IAAC Review, Kelly Haslam (who often speaks for SGB) wrote:

“When it comes to large-scale, reliable energy storage, Ontario doesn’t need to excavate the Escarpment and exploit Georgian Bay—we just need to look east. Hydro-Québec operates one of the largest and most dependable clean energy storage systems in the world… Ontario can tap into this clean, dispatchable power by expanding the east-west transmission grid—a solution already identified by the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) as both feasible and necessary. According to the IESO, Ontario could increase its connection to Quebec by up to 7,500 megawatts. And the cost? Far more reasonable.”

I’d like to ask the GBA, SGB, the OCAA, and Ms. Haslam, (and maybe the IESO too, if they aren’t being misquoted) the same questions I asked last time.

If you’re opposed to large scale green energy storage for Ontario? If you’re promoting your own “alternative” to safe, clean, and environmentally friendly pumped storage – located right here in Meaford? In Ontario where it’s both needed badly and needs to be under Ontario’s control? If your proposed “alternative” depends on purchasing excess power from someone else far away?

Shouldn’t you first find out if they have any? Do they have excess power to sell you? Can they even meet their own needs, let alone meet their contractual commitments to their existing customers?

See, the problem with electricity is that if you don’t have any, or even enough, sometimes in winter people die here.

If it’s dark in the house, and your teeth are chattering in the cold, complaining “But! But! We have a contract!!” never helps the situation if the other side has nothing to send you.

That was always nothing more than a bogus distraction. It wasn’t going to happen regardless. Hydro-Quebec (and Manitoba Hydro) were never going to sign new export contracts until they secured their own futures.

So. The next time someone tries to sell you the sleeves off of their vest? Tries out the old “Ontario wouldn’t need pumped storage electricity from Meaford if we would just purchase the excess electricity Quebec produces” on you?

Ask them “How’s that working out for New England?”

Bruce Mason, Meaford

Be the 1st to vote.

Popular this week

Latest news